Monday, April 1, 2013

Balancing Assessment's Effect on Education






It is an interesting time in education. On the one hand, it is a good thing that the current political climate is interested in improving education. However, in order to improve education, you have to understand how and what students need to learn. Because education uses community tax money, it is understandable that some people want to impose business models on our educational system. But what are the collateral costs? I believe that imposing this business model on the educational environment creates an obsession of pursuing quantitative assessments of teachers and students. What is lost when out of necessity to secure funding for our schools and livelihood we have to primarily focus on preparing for a specific type of test?
After reading Playing Their Way Into Literacies by Dr. Karen Wohlwend, the idea that we are depriving our students of educationally valuable play time is of course realized to be a downfall to the current testing obsessive culture. I would argue that just as importantly we are losing alternative perspectives on how to express our knowledge of the world. “An emphasis on accountability and standardization has prompted a regressive move to drill and memorization and a reduction in the flexible problem-solving and critical thinking that the discourse promotes.” (Wohlwend, 2011)  We are teaching our students what we value by what we test. If we are implying that we value this particular way of thinking, are we are taking away motivation and value from other forms of thinking and expressing ideas? This is especially troubling as the realities of advancing technologies are constantly expanding our ways of communicating as well as our perspectives of what text is.
I am not proposing that I am close to understanding what may be solution to this misalignment of goals and methods of education. I am just suggesting that the complexities of our current culture are creating the need to focus more on the delicate balance of future and current needs.  What we need to balance is the need to be teaching students how to understand the near future’s way of communicating and the very real need to assess both student’s and teacher’s abilities. There is no doubt that assessments are vital to the educational system. At what point do assessments start degrading the educational environment by depriving students the time to expand their thinking through play and of the understanding of the value of diverse thinking and expression?

Sunday, March 24, 2013

Why Making Time For Make Believe, Makes Sense




     My toddler recently was walking around our living room with his Dora the Explorer doll yelling with his hand cupped around his mouth. When I asked him what he needed, he turned to me and signed ‘where’. I realized that he was in the middle of a pretend play scenario where he and Dora were searching for her side kick, Boots who was apparently was stranded on top of the play kitchen. The extended rescue attempt ended up involving a stuffed macaw and a toy motorcycle. As soon as Boots was rescued, Dora was placed on a shelf and my son and Boots immediately began a new rescue effort again using the stuffed macaw and toy motorcycle. I was ecstatic during this forty-five minutes of play because it was an example of his cognitive ability. It showed how my non-verbal son was able to express a storyline and even have it evolve without the use of verbal or written language. Pretend play is a form of communicating that does not always require oral language.
     Of course, when verbal discourse is possible, it is a powerful way that children define shared meanings during pretend play. “When two or more children collaborate in play, they often find that they must stop to clarify shared meanings to keep the play scenario going.” (Wohlwend, 2011)  This negotiating the meaning and plot of the play scenario is an important way that children learn to be creative. They develop elaborate story lines and adapt them as they interface with other people’s ideas and things in the environment. Vygotsky(1935/1978) developed the idea that this ‘manipulation of meaning’ during pretend play is in fact a cognitive act that flows ‘directly to written language’.          
       This idea is particularly fascinating to me in terms of how important assessing play can be when dealing with children with different learning and/or communication styles. Raising a son with has excellent receptive language and almost no expressive language is a challenge. Due to his young age, assessing his cognitive abilities is almost completely reliant on watching how he plays and how he integrates verbal suggestions into his play. Besides both invented and ASL signs, facial expressions, and body language, play is his only way of expressing himself. Play is his only way of expressing the complex thoughts that are going on in his mind.
     Unfortunately, there is a pervasive misunderstanding that people with special needs always have cognitive delay. In his short three years, I have already run into this misperception a remarkable amount of times. We know that he has cognitive strength because of his complex, adaptable, and varied play scenarios. Play is central to his ability to interact with the world and express his mind. Dr. Wohlwend makes an excellent case that dramatic or pretend play is an essential part of any child’s mental development of various literacies. I believe that a case can also be made that dramatic play can be even more vital for children who are dealing with a communication issue. This could be a child who has emerging English speaking skills or a child with a communication delay. For these students, making time to play in our classrooms is a foundation that they must be given so that they can work to increase their abilities in multiple literacies.     
      Dr. Wohlwend suggests that the concept of literacy is being redefined to include the vast amount of different literacies that we use to communicate in today’s culture. As the concept of literacy is distilled down to how we navigate situations and make meaning with others, we must look more seriously at how play is a form of communication that strengthens and sculpts other literacies. Play is an ingrained practice of social negotiation that all children do. It seems to be a biological need. Play needs to be giving time and space to be expressed in the classroom. Play seems to be the foundation for social communication. Communication is the foundation for all future learning. It only makes sense to make room for children to explore the art of communicating in the classroom.         

Saturday, March 16, 2013

Beyond Miscue Analysis: Dissecting Comprehension



          
     There is no doubt that having on my tool belt the ability to do a miscue analysis will be immensely beneficial when working with emergent readers. Being able to tease out the mental sources of their miscues and address them is a highly valuable skill. The fact that a miscue analysis also addresses the amount of comprehension that a reader has is extremely important and useful part of this analysis process. But what does it really mean to comprehend a text? Are there different levels of comprehension? What is a reader able to accomplish with that understanding?  The process of miscue analysis touches upon gaging the comprehension of a reader, but I believe that it is important for educators to go beyond that small barometer and dissect the multiple aspects of comprehension.
            Investigating the many levels of comprehension is a study that could take a lifetime. In Chapter 9 of Catching Readers Before They Fall, Johnson and Keier discuss the techniques of using inference and summarizing to expand and use student’s comprehension. They define that a reader is making an inference when a reader can “take the words of the author and combine them with their activated schema to draw conclusions about the story or the information presented in the text.”  It is important to realize that students come to the class already knowing how to infer. They suggest teachers can increase comprehension by “building on this existing strategy”. To be able to combined existing knowledge with the newly acquired information from text is a powerful skill that can last a life time. Being able to summarize and essentially distill the main points out of the text is a strategy that first requires students to comprehend text. This process can also increase the level of comprehension. Honing these skills by modeling them as well as providing students with ample opportunities to practice them are valuable strategies to weave into instructional time.
However, being able to infer from or summarize a text is not the only way to gage comprehension. In a Voices of Literacy podcast, Dr. Paula Schwanenflugel discusses her research on reading fluency. She implies that more attention should be paid to the reader’s expression. The prosody, or appropriate intonation and natural pauses, that a reader uses is another way to assess comprehension. In order to use appropriate intonation and pausing, a reader has to understand what the text is trying to communicate. Listening to and teaching a student about expression is an important part of increasing comprehension. Dr. Schwanenflugel advocates that parents and educators directly discuss expression skills with children.
Keier and Johnson also discuss the importance of having direct conversations with students about inferring and summarizing. There is one point that they made that I do disagree with. They state that “it is not important for the students to stop their thinking processes to determine what strategy or operation their brains are busy performing.” While you certainly do not want to constantly interrupt a child’s thought process, I think that considerably merit and motivation can be found in highlighting and explaining to children that they are in fact using specific higher level thinking skills. To notice that a child is naturally inferring from a text and pointing out this skill to them could be an immense confidence booster. Of course, a balance must be made between letting them processes information and explaining to them how they are doing it. This discussion brings to mind my experience with learning about constructivism in a recent math pedagogy course. I had made it all the way to graduate school with the underlying belief that I was somehow faking it in math classes. I have always tended to process math problems in a slightly different way than most of my math educators. Despite being a good math student, I also suspected that I was somehow faking it. That is until I learned about the multiple ways that people understand and construct math. There is power in pointing out to children that the way they think about things might be the similar to others thinking or completely unique. It is important to not underestimate the motivation and self-confidence that can be gained by taking a minute to explain what and why we are teaching a particular thinking process.      

           
   
   

Monday, March 4, 2013

The Politics of Teaching



            I never thought of myself as a person that would go into politics. My bubble of naïveté has been burst in the last few years as I have realized that it will be extremely difficult if not impossible to not become embroiled in the politics of our time as a public school educator. Especially, with events such as this week’s sequester cuts soon to hit our society so hard. As a new educator, it is vital for me to understand that current politics are always going to significant effect my professional life. The impact of the sequester cuts alone will surely impact the realities of resources available to educators and students. These new cuts, such as the $633 million cut from the Department of Education’s Special Education programs, will in no doubt affect every educator and student in this country. 
            The optimist in me believes that no one is waking up in the morning with the intent of making education worse for children. However, it seems that well meaning actions are consistently causing harm. What is confusing is why there seems to be a large disconnect between what literacy researchers are saying and what politicians, legislators, and administrators are pushing for. In the article Dilemmas and Discourses of Learning to Write: Assessment as a Contested Site, Karen Wohlwend discusses the idea that the pedagogical practices that are supported by professional literature are often not the practices that are supported by the people supporting the high stakes assessment based accountability practices. How do we bridge this immense ideological chasm?  
One of the major shifts in high stakes assessments that was highlighted by Dr. Caitlyn Dooley in her Voices of Literacy interview, is the change in the degree of use of the tests. These tests, which can have a useful and balanced place in education, are now being used for major decision making at the individual and funding level based on the results of only one test. These tests now are weighted far more than they used to be. What has been the benefit of this? Can positive results be shown? Can negative results be shown?

Dick Allington and P. David Pearson’s conversation transcribed in The Causalities of Policy on Early Literacy Development, was particularly enlightening. The complex nature of the politics in regards to reading pedagogy legislation that they have both had the opportunity to witness in the last several decades was fascinating to reflect on. It was also a little infuriating. The fact that there were reports of corruption and improper steering of which reading assessment systems should be used if an organization wanted funding is disturbing. I was not aware of this scandal that lead to “several key Department of Education administrators” losing their jobs. These respected education researchers mentioning this debacle made me want to understand more about the development of the systems and the evolution of the political state that the field of education is currently boiling in.

I briefly researched and compiled some information and definitions of the programs and legislative acts that are mentioned in this article. 


DIBELS (Dynamic Indicators of Basic Early Literacy Skills):
DIBELS is a series of 6 short (one-minute) assessments that can be used to monitor students reading skills progress. The data collected and be put into multiple grafts.
-First  developed at the University of Oregon

-There are two main organizations that run DIEBALS programs

https://dibels.uoregon.edu/-non-profit university affiliated

this newer branch is run by the authors, for profit

Nowhere on the websites, did I find an indicator that this is how you should sculpt instruction but just to identify who needs more intervention.

Reading First
Reading First is a government run funding program that awards money for reading programs that are “scientifically proven”. It is one way that “states and districts receive support to apply scientifically based reading research” in the classroom.

National Reading Panel

“In 1997, Congress asked the Director of the National Institute of Child Health and Human Development (NICHD), along with the Secretary of Education, to convene a national panel on reading. The National Reading Panel (NRP) was asked by Congress to assess the status of research-based knowledge about reading, including the effectiveness of various approaches to teaching children to read. The panel was made up of 14 people, including leading scientists in reading research, representatives of colleges of education, teachers, educational administrators, and parents. The NRP met over a period of two years to discuss their findings and prepare the results in two reports and a video titled, "Teaching Children to Read."

“Five Pillars created by the National Reading Panel”
Five Pillars of Reading Instruction
Phonemic Awareness
Phonics and Concepts about Print
Fluency
Vocabulary
Comprehension

Reading Recovery
“Reading Recovery is a highly effective short-term intervention of one-to-one tutoring for low-achieving first graders. The intervention is most effective when it is available to all students who need it and is used as a supplement to good classroom teaching.”


A Nation at Risk: The Imperative For Educational Reform
Is a report written in 1983 by Ronald Reagan’s National Commission on Excellence in Education.
“Its publication is considered a landmark event in modern American educational history. Among other things, the report contributed to the ever-growing (and still present) sense that American schools are failing, and it touched off a wave of local, state, and federal reform efforts.”

No Child Left Behind Act
This Act was signed into law in 2002. This act established the use of the Annual Yearly Progress system.
What was new information for me was that this is a reauthorization of the Elementary and Secondary Education Act which was signed into law in 1965. This act implemented the Title 1 program.

I compiled this list because I felt that I needed to understand these programs better in order to understand the discourse going on about assessment practices. I do think that P. David Pearson’s idea about teacher education is important. “We have to prepare folks in a broader way with more transferable skills, strategies, and practices that they can adapt to materials they encounter when they get into school.” Keeping myself abreast with the various movements of reading education practices and legislation is a responsibility of being an educator.

Sunday, February 24, 2013

The Key is Comprehension


It is no secret that the No Child Left Behind Act has had an enormous impact on the field and practice of education. It is reasonable to assume that the influence of this act will be felt in many ways for many generations. What is interesting is how much dispute there is about the solidity of the research that this influential legislation was based on. During Dr. David Pearson’s Voices of Literacy interview, he discusses the ‘alleged’ scientific research that the No Child Left Behind and Reading First was based on. The most vital issue that he highlighted was the lack of research showing that these programs positively impacted student’s comprehension skills. While there is some supporting research indicating that these programs make a positive impact on the age that students can read individual words, there is no solid evidence that comprehension is improved. What is the rationale for the use of the resources and the energy of overhauling the entire educational system if there is not proof that the main goal of reading, comprehending the information that a text is trying to communicate, is impacted by these efforts.


        The issue is not that there is no merit to teaching phonics. It is just not the only approach that we need to be focusing our energy on.  Dr. Pearson comments, “There is a lot of other work to be done. There’s issues of helping kids acquire a rich vocabulary, oral language development, developing a repertoire reading comprehension processes and strategies that you can use when you encounter really, really tricky text and the like.” He suggests that assessments that are more based on comprehension need to be developed. If we only test the individual components of reading, are we missing the bigger picture of what we are trying to accomplish: the ability to comprehend text?
With this idea in mind, the development of a more holistically assessment of how a child systematically approaches reading becomes an extremely useful tool. In her article A New Spin on Miscue Analysis: Using Spider Charts to Web Reading Processes, Karen E. Wohlwend introduces the tool of using spider charts to help quickly visually assess the balance of reading cueing systems that a student is using at a given time. What makes this tool particularly relevant is that it helps an educator see the specific strengths and weaknesses that make up a student’s repertoire of reading strategies. It helps an educator to identify a clear area that they can work towards improving. Dr. Wohlwend reminds us that this type of spider chart “is a snapshot of reading processes with a specific book at a specific moment in time, and that readers and readings are always changing.” If students are assessed over time, this tool can help show us if our teaching approaches are helping students develop a more balanced, effective approach to reading. It can help educators to evaluate if a particular approach is working and help direct and redirect pedagogical choices. This technique also provides a visual assessment to show to administrators, parents, legislators, and other educators. One of the most helpful aspects of this tool is that it can help identify a student that is ‘performing’ a read aloud well but not comprehending the material read. It helps educators keep an eye on what strategies are being used without losing sight of the fact that comprehension is key.  
       

Sunday, February 17, 2013

Time to Tend the Garden




In Kath Glasswell and Michael Ford’s article, Let’s Start Leveling about Leveling, they bring up the idea that “leveling takes a complex idea and makes it too simple.” This form of assessment ignores too many factors. Is the student comfortable, are they sick, did they sleep well, are they intimidated by assessment practices. All of these things could influence a student, causing their assessment scores to not be a good indicator of where they are academically or what areas they need to progress in. Glasswell and Ford also point out the dangers of you only choosing your instruction practices by the reading level. If you only address what reading level a student appears to be on, you are in danger of ignoring how they are actually thinking about reading. Can they read perfectly yet not comprehend? Can they barely read a sentence out loud but silently read with excellent comprehension?
Once again we have the issue of prescribed assessments with prescribed fixes. These prescribed assessments, whether they are standardized testing or assessing for reading levels, might work beautifully for one or many children. But what happens when one size does not fit all?
“When orthodoxy takes hold, a focus on ‘one right way’ to engage in that useful practice can lead to inflexibly implementation of it.” (Opitz and Ford, 2001) It seems that our country is trying more and more to approach education in a strict orthodox manner. It is not necessarily looking at long term studies for ideas on how to improve education.  Many people are searching for the silver bullet to fix the educational system. There is no time to wait for longitudinal research; not with the realities of 4 year election cycles influencing the decisions. It seems that more and more quantitative results are being sought so that people can react to them. The acquisition of these quantitative assessments seem to be so they can claim victory or point fingers. It seems to not matter whether or not positive results are actually there.
In her Voice of Literacy podcast interview, Dr. Heidi Anne Mesmer states,
“We need principled research on text that takes a longitudinal look at how the content of the text, the sequence of what’s in that, the repetition and the pacing are all developed across time. For that we need a clear commitment at the federal level to fund text research. Right now, the way text books are developed and adopted is the wild west of market forces.”
 If we are not basing these sweeping narrowing changes to our educational system on scientific studies, what are we basing them on? Who stands to benefit the most? I am starting to believe less and less that students will benefit from the implementation of rigid uniform assessment and prescribed responses. If we take away the flexibility of the educators to adapt to the complex needs of the child that can only be assessed by personally getting to know the child overtime, then are we really improving the education system?            
            Glasswell and Ford also discuss the idea that “Reading levels are not the same as reading needs.” Whether these are reading level assessments or standardized tests based off of the Common Core standards, you cannot fully understand how to address the academic needs of the students without first knowing who they are, how they think, and what they know. I am speaking of the aspects of the child that are not able to be quantitatively reduced to fit into politicians talking points.
    
Teaching is more like tending a garden then baking bread. When you bake bread, you measure out specific ingredients in specific amounts and bake it at a specific temperature for a specific length of time. When you garden, you provide a rich environment and monitor how each plant is developing overtime. You make changes as you go to accommodate the needs of each plant as it grows and shows the good observer what it needs.
            More and more I feel that we are being asked to provide the recipe for good teacher, when we should be asking how we can be better gardeners.