I never thought of myself
as a person that would go into politics. My bubble of naïveté has been burst in
the last few years as I have realized that it will be extremely difficult if
not impossible to not become embroiled in the politics of our time as a public
school educator. Especially, with events such as this week’s sequester cuts
soon to hit our society so hard. As a new educator, it is vital for me to
understand that current politics are always going to significant effect my
professional life. The impact of the sequester cuts alone will surely impact
the realities of resources available to educators and students. These new cuts,
such as the $633 million cut from the Department of Education’s Special
Education programs, will in no doubt affect every educator and student in this
country.
The optimist in me believes
that no one is waking up in the morning with the intent of making education
worse for children. However, it seems that well meaning actions are
consistently causing harm. What is confusing is why there seems to be a large disconnect
between what literacy researchers are saying and what politicians, legislators,
and administrators are pushing for. In the article
Dilemmas and Discourses of Learning to Write: Assessment as a Contested
Site, Karen Wohlwend discusses the idea that the pedagogical practices
that are supported by professional literature are often not the practices that
are supported by the people supporting the high stakes assessment based
accountability practices. How do we bridge this immense ideological chasm?
One of the major shifts in high
stakes assessments that was highlighted by Dr. Caitlyn Dooley in her Voices of Literacy interview, is the
change in the degree of use of the tests. These tests, which can have a useful
and balanced place in education, are now being used for major decision making
at the individual and funding level based on the results of only one test.
These tests now are weighted far more than they used to be. What has been the
benefit of this? Can positive results be shown? Can negative results be shown?
Dick Allington and P. David
Pearson’s conversation transcribed in The
Causalities of Policy on Early Literacy Development, was particularly
enlightening. The complex nature of the politics in regards to reading pedagogy
legislation that they have both had the opportunity to witness in the last
several decades was fascinating to reflect on. It was also a little
infuriating. The fact that there were reports of corruption and improper
steering of which reading assessment systems should be used if an organization
wanted funding is disturbing. I was not aware of this scandal that lead to
“several key Department of Education administrators” losing their jobs. These
respected education researchers mentioning this debacle made me want to
understand more about the development of the systems and the evolution of the
political state that the field of education is currently boiling in.
I briefly researched and compiled some information and
definitions of the programs and legislative acts that are mentioned in this
article.
DIBELS (Dynamic
Indicators of Basic Early Literacy Skills):
DIBELS is a series of 6 short
(one-minute) assessments that can be used to monitor students reading skills
progress. The data collected and be put into multiple grafts.
-First developed at the University of Oregon
-There are two main organizations
that run DIEBALS programs
this newer branch is run by the authors, for profit
Nowhere on the websites, did I find an indicator that this
is how you should sculpt instruction but just to identify who needs more
intervention.
Reading First
Reading
First is a government run funding program that awards money for reading
programs that are “scientifically proven”. It is one way that “states and
districts receive support to apply scientifically based reading research” in
the classroom.
National Reading Panel
“In 1997, Congress asked the
Director of the National Institute of Child Health and Human Development
(NICHD), along with the Secretary of Education, to convene a national panel on
reading. The National Reading Panel (NRP) was asked by Congress to assess the
status of research-based knowledge about reading, including the effectiveness
of various approaches to teaching children to read. The panel was made up of 14
people, including leading scientists in reading research, representatives of
colleges of
education, teachers, educational administrators, and parents. The NRP met over
a period of two years to discuss their findings and prepare the results in two
reports and a video titled, "Teaching Children to Read."
“Five Pillars created
by the National Reading
Panel”
Five Pillars of Reading Instruction
Phonemic Awareness
Phonics and Concepts about Print
Fluency
Vocabulary
Comprehension
Reading Recovery
“Reading Recovery is a highly effective short-term
intervention of one-to-one tutoring for low-achieving first graders. The
intervention is most effective when it is available to all students who need it
and is used as a supplement to good classroom teaching.”
A Nation at Risk: The Imperative For Educational
Reform
Is a report written in 1983 by Ronald Reagan’s National
Commission on Excellence in Education.
“Its publication is considered a landmark event in modern
American educational history. Among other things, the report contributed to the
ever-growing (and still present) sense that American schools are failing, and
it touched off a wave of local, state, and federal reform efforts.”
No Child Left Behind
Act
This Act was signed into law in 2002. This act established
the use of the Annual Yearly Progress system.
What was new information for me was that this is a
reauthorization of the Elementary and Secondary Education Act which was signed
into law in 1965. This act implemented the Title 1 program.
I compiled this list because I felt
that I needed to understand these programs better in order to understand the
discourse going on about assessment practices. I do think that P. David
Pearson’s idea about teacher education is important. “We have to prepare folks
in a broader way with more transferable skills, strategies, and practices that
they can adapt to materials they encounter when they get into school.” Keeping
myself abreast with the various movements of reading education practices and
legislation is a responsibility of being an educator.