The
issue is not that there is no merit to teaching phonics. It is just not the
only approach that we need to be focusing our energy on. Dr. Pearson comments, “There is a lot of other
work to be done. There’s issues of helping kids acquire a rich vocabulary, oral
language development, developing a repertoire reading comprehension processes
and strategies that you can use when you encounter really, really tricky text
and the like.” He suggests that assessments that are more based on
comprehension need to be developed. If we only test the individual components
of reading, are we missing the bigger picture of what we are trying to accomplish:
the ability to comprehend text?
With this idea in mind, the development
of a more holistically assessment of how a child systematically approaches
reading becomes an extremely useful tool. In her article A New Spin on
Miscue Analysis: Using Spider Charts to Web Reading Processes, Karen E.
Wohlwend introduces the tool of using spider charts to help quickly visually
assess the balance of reading cueing systems that a student is using at a given
time. What makes this tool particularly relevant is that it helps an educator
see the specific strengths and weaknesses that make up a student’s repertoire of
reading strategies. It helps an educator to identify a clear area that they can
work towards improving. Dr. Wohlwend reminds us that this type of spider chart “is
a snapshot of reading processes with a specific book at a specific moment in
time, and that readers and readings are always changing.” If students are
assessed over time, this tool can help show us if our teaching approaches are
helping students develop a more balanced, effective approach to reading. It can
help educators to evaluate if a particular approach is working and help direct
and redirect pedagogical choices. This technique also provides a visual
assessment to show to administrators, parents, legislators, and other educators.
One of the most helpful aspects of this tool is that it can help identify a
student that is ‘performing’ a read aloud well but not comprehending the
material read. It helps educators keep an eye on what strategies are being used
without losing sight of the fact that comprehension is key.