Sunday, February 24, 2013

The Key is Comprehension


It is no secret that the No Child Left Behind Act has had an enormous impact on the field and practice of education. It is reasonable to assume that the influence of this act will be felt in many ways for many generations. What is interesting is how much dispute there is about the solidity of the research that this influential legislation was based on. During Dr. David Pearson’s Voices of Literacy interview, he discusses the ‘alleged’ scientific research that the No Child Left Behind and Reading First was based on. The most vital issue that he highlighted was the lack of research showing that these programs positively impacted student’s comprehension skills. While there is some supporting research indicating that these programs make a positive impact on the age that students can read individual words, there is no solid evidence that comprehension is improved. What is the rationale for the use of the resources and the energy of overhauling the entire educational system if there is not proof that the main goal of reading, comprehending the information that a text is trying to communicate, is impacted by these efforts.


        The issue is not that there is no merit to teaching phonics. It is just not the only approach that we need to be focusing our energy on.  Dr. Pearson comments, “There is a lot of other work to be done. There’s issues of helping kids acquire a rich vocabulary, oral language development, developing a repertoire reading comprehension processes and strategies that you can use when you encounter really, really tricky text and the like.” He suggests that assessments that are more based on comprehension need to be developed. If we only test the individual components of reading, are we missing the bigger picture of what we are trying to accomplish: the ability to comprehend text?
With this idea in mind, the development of a more holistically assessment of how a child systematically approaches reading becomes an extremely useful tool. In her article A New Spin on Miscue Analysis: Using Spider Charts to Web Reading Processes, Karen E. Wohlwend introduces the tool of using spider charts to help quickly visually assess the balance of reading cueing systems that a student is using at a given time. What makes this tool particularly relevant is that it helps an educator see the specific strengths and weaknesses that make up a student’s repertoire of reading strategies. It helps an educator to identify a clear area that they can work towards improving. Dr. Wohlwend reminds us that this type of spider chart “is a snapshot of reading processes with a specific book at a specific moment in time, and that readers and readings are always changing.” If students are assessed over time, this tool can help show us if our teaching approaches are helping students develop a more balanced, effective approach to reading. It can help educators to evaluate if a particular approach is working and help direct and redirect pedagogical choices. This technique also provides a visual assessment to show to administrators, parents, legislators, and other educators. One of the most helpful aspects of this tool is that it can help identify a student that is ‘performing’ a read aloud well but not comprehending the material read. It helps educators keep an eye on what strategies are being used without losing sight of the fact that comprehension is key.  
       

Sunday, February 17, 2013

Time to Tend the Garden




In Kath Glasswell and Michael Ford’s article, Let’s Start Leveling about Leveling, they bring up the idea that “leveling takes a complex idea and makes it too simple.” This form of assessment ignores too many factors. Is the student comfortable, are they sick, did they sleep well, are they intimidated by assessment practices. All of these things could influence a student, causing their assessment scores to not be a good indicator of where they are academically or what areas they need to progress in. Glasswell and Ford also point out the dangers of you only choosing your instruction practices by the reading level. If you only address what reading level a student appears to be on, you are in danger of ignoring how they are actually thinking about reading. Can they read perfectly yet not comprehend? Can they barely read a sentence out loud but silently read with excellent comprehension?
Once again we have the issue of prescribed assessments with prescribed fixes. These prescribed assessments, whether they are standardized testing or assessing for reading levels, might work beautifully for one or many children. But what happens when one size does not fit all?
“When orthodoxy takes hold, a focus on ‘one right way’ to engage in that useful practice can lead to inflexibly implementation of it.” (Opitz and Ford, 2001) It seems that our country is trying more and more to approach education in a strict orthodox manner. It is not necessarily looking at long term studies for ideas on how to improve education.  Many people are searching for the silver bullet to fix the educational system. There is no time to wait for longitudinal research; not with the realities of 4 year election cycles influencing the decisions. It seems that more and more quantitative results are being sought so that people can react to them. The acquisition of these quantitative assessments seem to be so they can claim victory or point fingers. It seems to not matter whether or not positive results are actually there.
In her Voice of Literacy podcast interview, Dr. Heidi Anne Mesmer states,
“We need principled research on text that takes a longitudinal look at how the content of the text, the sequence of what’s in that, the repetition and the pacing are all developed across time. For that we need a clear commitment at the federal level to fund text research. Right now, the way text books are developed and adopted is the wild west of market forces.”
 If we are not basing these sweeping narrowing changes to our educational system on scientific studies, what are we basing them on? Who stands to benefit the most? I am starting to believe less and less that students will benefit from the implementation of rigid uniform assessment and prescribed responses. If we take away the flexibility of the educators to adapt to the complex needs of the child that can only be assessed by personally getting to know the child overtime, then are we really improving the education system?            
            Glasswell and Ford also discuss the idea that “Reading levels are not the same as reading needs.” Whether these are reading level assessments or standardized tests based off of the Common Core standards, you cannot fully understand how to address the academic needs of the students without first knowing who they are, how they think, and what they know. I am speaking of the aspects of the child that are not able to be quantitatively reduced to fit into politicians talking points.
    
Teaching is more like tending a garden then baking bread. When you bake bread, you measure out specific ingredients in specific amounts and bake it at a specific temperature for a specific length of time. When you garden, you provide a rich environment and monitor how each plant is developing overtime. You make changes as you go to accommodate the needs of each plant as it grows and shows the good observer what it needs.
            More and more I feel that we are being asked to provide the recipe for good teacher, when we should be asking how we can be better gardeners.

 

Sunday, February 10, 2013

Modeling Thinking: The Importance of Showing the Jumbled Mess of Thoughts.



I truly believed that I was ‘faking it’ in all of the many math courses that I took in my life until this past semester. I have always had tricks to remember ideas and little narratives that helped me remember strategies. I always seemed to approach a problem a little differently than my teachers. In math pedagogy class this past semester, we started to discuss the varieties of ways that students might construct math understanding. I realized that my math tricks where just how I constructed my understanding of math and were not any less valid just because they might have been different from how my primary and secondary teachers thought and constructed their own understandings. It took my professor discussing the variety of ways that people can think about a given subject to become enlightened about this concept.  
In Chapter 2 of Reading with Meaning, Debbie Miller discusses the importance of “thinking through the text together”. She describes a Read aloud/Think aloud activity where she has practiced with the book and decided on sharing her thoughts that illustrate the thinking processes that she wants to model. She states that these thoughts must be clear and precise and be chosen in order to illustrate a specific skill that she wants the students to develop. Over time, she will expose the students to a variety of thinking models. Her thoughts might seem random to the students because they do not know what Mrs. Miller’s schema is. When I think back to my belief that I was ‘faking it’ in math, I realize that I would have benefitted greatly from having someone model their own thinking process in this subject for me. As a child’s thinking processes develop and change, we forget that some styles of thinking are entirely new to them. The central idea that is developing from this text-to-self connection is that we must teach kids about the sometimes messy nature of initial ponderings as well as the skill of focusing and refining their thoughts. If we only ever model our finished thoughts and not mess of constructing them, they might not understand that your thoughts can often initially be jumbled. Your thoughts being messy at first and then focusing your thoughts to be more clear is a part of the process.
In Using Categories to Teach Vocabulary to Preschoolers, Dr. Susan Neuman points out that to help a child have the necessary tools to understand and expand their thinking; it is paramount that we work to expand their vocabulary. Debbie Miller states “I remind myself (again) that children can use a strategy without fully understanding it and that they will gradually gain control of it through continued modeling and guided practice”. {text to text connection} I would argue that the same can be said about how a child might use complex vocabulary. They might play with the new and exciting word. They might use a new word correctly or incorrectly at first. However, this personal word play becomes a self-teaching mechanism to explore new language. For me, this belief reinforces the benefit of using ‘adult’ language with children. I would rephrase the term ‘adult’ language and suggest that parents and educators just use the entirety of the language when speaking with children. Do not filter out words that you believe that they might be ‘over their heads’. Use the word and then directly teach them what it means so that it becomes a part of the child’s own schema. Show the connection between words by teaching words in categories that help students make sense of them. As Dr. Neuman’s research showed, helping a child create a large vocabulary early on can be extremely beneficial. To do this, it is important to start with the bar high in terms of what you expect children to understand. Just as importantly, create an environment where it is safe to admit that you do not understand and where questioning and clarifying is valued. 

{Text-to-self connection}
My husband and I both come from families that use the entire language when speaking to children. Things are explained things early on. I have used this comment as a quick way to explain both of our families’ philosophies before. “We both come from families were we were given a biology book rather than a stork story.” We have both been raised were we were invited into conversations from an early age and were not expected to be quiet. Our parents explained vocabulary and did not ‘dumb down’ their language. Of course, this is an important part of our own parental philosophy.  We do have an interesting challenge with our son. His comprehension and receptive language is great. His thought processes seem developmentally appropriate when closely examined. However, his perinatal stroke did greatly affect his ability to produce expressive oral language. So how do we teach him to understand and express advanced vocabulary at the young age of 3? Or rather, how to we check for comprehension. For us, the answer is sign language. We do experience the issue that he is developing his own sign faster than we are learning American Sign Language. While this is a positive sign of cognitive development, it does create the need for use to teach him to convert self-made signs into ASL on a regular basis. This is normally a relatively painless effort as long as we fully understand his vocabulary. However, he might have a sign that we do not know the definition of. We must figure out or he must teach us what he means. From that point on, we work on marrying the two signs and eventually wean the invented sign out of use. As parents of course, we want to give him the best leg up possible, especially since he started life with more trials than most. We attempt to connect sign, oral and written text often. I like to imagine that this extensive work with deciphering signs and sign approximations and connecting them with oral and written language must be positively impacting the neuroplasticity of the areas of the brain that handle language comprehension and expression. Like much of teaching though, all of this is an internal, unseen, and unheard process. I must have faith that we will see the evidence of this internal work eventually. We might not yet be able to hear his diverse word diet but we can see much of it.       

Sunday, February 3, 2013

Literacy: The Long Culturally Influenced Adventure


A 2-year-old child walks into a local restaurant with a tank of lobsters in the entrance way. His face immediately beams with recognition and he throws himself on the floor and starts to laugh throwing his feet in the air. To others witnessing this scene, there was abundant confusion. The mother smiled as she recognized that he was connecting the tank of doomed crustaceans to the cartoon character “Laughing Lobster” on the video LeapFrog: Phonics Farm. This character is used to teach the connection of the letter “L” with the /L/ sound. This young child has a solid foundation of understanding that certain letters represent certain sounds.



                                                                                                         
Does the fact that this child has shown that he has developed alphabet awareness mean that the child will have an easier time developing further phonological awareness, spelling, and reading skills? According to Dr. Shayne Piasta of Ohio State University, there is ‘minimal evidence of transfer of alphabet instruction to phonological awareness, spelling or reading skills’. Importantly, she does highlight that there is currently a lack of comprehensive research that follows children from the stage of alphabet awareness through to the stage of being fluent readers. Assumptions can be made that early alphabet awareness does increase these later skills; however, there is not enough research to confirm this correlation. 

            So what does that mean? Should we be stressing alphabet awareness early on?
           There are innumerably ways to expose very young children to letters. Many toys, board books and videos feature a focus on the alphabet and are marketed to be used with preliterate children. Even without definitive supporting research, our culture promotes the idea that early exposure to letters helps children acquire reading skills. It is ingrained in our culture that ‘good parenting’ involves exposure to the alphabet early on. This is something that our culture believes to be true without any supporting scientific evidence. 

Similarly, in Catherine Compton-Lilly’s article “Sounding Out”: A Pervasive Cultural Model Of Reading, the idea is presented that many home cultures and our instructional culture focuses on the strategy of ‘sounding out’ a word to promote emergent reading skills. Compton-Lilly implies that this one strategy is focused on disproportionate to its usefulness. In Figure #3 in the article, she lists a variety of strategies used in the first, fourth, and fifth grades. According to her chart, sounding it out did appear to be a successful strategy that resulted in less miscues. However, this strategy was used far less then it was discussed by students, parents and educators. It is important to understand that ‘sounding out’ can be a valid strategy. It just seems to take up a larger portion of the spotlight than it needs to. It appears to be the mantra of parents and educators and so becomes the mantra for emergent readers. The challenge is to teach students to have other strategies on the tip of their tongue and in mind as they try to read. These strategies  include but are not limited to  checking for context, sense making, looking at the first letter, trying it again, connecting it to the meaning of known words and the visual similarities of known words. It is not that we should stop teaching children to ‘sound it out’, it is just that we have to provide them with additional approaches as well.

Now fast forward through the stage of the preliterate child, the stages of the emergent and proficient reader, and arrive at the literacy level of a graduate student. Here we are continuing to expand our knowledge base by beginning to become literate in the field of literacy. In From Phonics to Fluency, Rasinski and Padak throw us a lifeline by condensing into a list the abundant new terms and concepts that we need to become fluent in. We are still increasing our literacy. Hopefully, this will be true for the rest of our lives.
With this said, is it every too early to start this great adventure? As long as approaching alphabet awareness is relaxed and fun, can it be too early? I do not think so. Especially when early literacy lessons can be something as fun as a dance party with songs like these: