Monday, April 1, 2013

Balancing Assessment's Effect on Education






It is an interesting time in education. On the one hand, it is a good thing that the current political climate is interested in improving education. However, in order to improve education, you have to understand how and what students need to learn. Because education uses community tax money, it is understandable that some people want to impose business models on our educational system. But what are the collateral costs? I believe that imposing this business model on the educational environment creates an obsession of pursuing quantitative assessments of teachers and students. What is lost when out of necessity to secure funding for our schools and livelihood we have to primarily focus on preparing for a specific type of test?
After reading Playing Their Way Into Literacies by Dr. Karen Wohlwend, the idea that we are depriving our students of educationally valuable play time is of course realized to be a downfall to the current testing obsessive culture. I would argue that just as importantly we are losing alternative perspectives on how to express our knowledge of the world. “An emphasis on accountability and standardization has prompted a regressive move to drill and memorization and a reduction in the flexible problem-solving and critical thinking that the discourse promotes.” (Wohlwend, 2011)  We are teaching our students what we value by what we test. If we are implying that we value this particular way of thinking, are we are taking away motivation and value from other forms of thinking and expressing ideas? This is especially troubling as the realities of advancing technologies are constantly expanding our ways of communicating as well as our perspectives of what text is.
I am not proposing that I am close to understanding what may be solution to this misalignment of goals and methods of education. I am just suggesting that the complexities of our current culture are creating the need to focus more on the delicate balance of future and current needs.  What we need to balance is the need to be teaching students how to understand the near future’s way of communicating and the very real need to assess both student’s and teacher’s abilities. There is no doubt that assessments are vital to the educational system. At what point do assessments start degrading the educational environment by depriving students the time to expand their thinking through play and of the understanding of the value of diverse thinking and expression?

No comments:

Post a Comment