Sunday, February 3, 2013

Literacy: The Long Culturally Influenced Adventure


A 2-year-old child walks into a local restaurant with a tank of lobsters in the entrance way. His face immediately beams with recognition and he throws himself on the floor and starts to laugh throwing his feet in the air. To others witnessing this scene, there was abundant confusion. The mother smiled as she recognized that he was connecting the tank of doomed crustaceans to the cartoon character “Laughing Lobster” on the video LeapFrog: Phonics Farm. This character is used to teach the connection of the letter “L” with the /L/ sound. This young child has a solid foundation of understanding that certain letters represent certain sounds.



                                                                                                         
Does the fact that this child has shown that he has developed alphabet awareness mean that the child will have an easier time developing further phonological awareness, spelling, and reading skills? According to Dr. Shayne Piasta of Ohio State University, there is ‘minimal evidence of transfer of alphabet instruction to phonological awareness, spelling or reading skills’. Importantly, she does highlight that there is currently a lack of comprehensive research that follows children from the stage of alphabet awareness through to the stage of being fluent readers. Assumptions can be made that early alphabet awareness does increase these later skills; however, there is not enough research to confirm this correlation. 

            So what does that mean? Should we be stressing alphabet awareness early on?
           There are innumerably ways to expose very young children to letters. Many toys, board books and videos feature a focus on the alphabet and are marketed to be used with preliterate children. Even without definitive supporting research, our culture promotes the idea that early exposure to letters helps children acquire reading skills. It is ingrained in our culture that ‘good parenting’ involves exposure to the alphabet early on. This is something that our culture believes to be true without any supporting scientific evidence. 

Similarly, in Catherine Compton-Lilly’s article “Sounding Out”: A Pervasive Cultural Model Of Reading, the idea is presented that many home cultures and our instructional culture focuses on the strategy of ‘sounding out’ a word to promote emergent reading skills. Compton-Lilly implies that this one strategy is focused on disproportionate to its usefulness. In Figure #3 in the article, she lists a variety of strategies used in the first, fourth, and fifth grades. According to her chart, sounding it out did appear to be a successful strategy that resulted in less miscues. However, this strategy was used far less then it was discussed by students, parents and educators. It is important to understand that ‘sounding out’ can be a valid strategy. It just seems to take up a larger portion of the spotlight than it needs to. It appears to be the mantra of parents and educators and so becomes the mantra for emergent readers. The challenge is to teach students to have other strategies on the tip of their tongue and in mind as they try to read. These strategies  include but are not limited to  checking for context, sense making, looking at the first letter, trying it again, connecting it to the meaning of known words and the visual similarities of known words. It is not that we should stop teaching children to ‘sound it out’, it is just that we have to provide them with additional approaches as well.

Now fast forward through the stage of the preliterate child, the stages of the emergent and proficient reader, and arrive at the literacy level of a graduate student. Here we are continuing to expand our knowledge base by beginning to become literate in the field of literacy. In From Phonics to Fluency, Rasinski and Padak throw us a lifeline by condensing into a list the abundant new terms and concepts that we need to become fluent in. We are still increasing our literacy. Hopefully, this will be true for the rest of our lives.
With this said, is it every too early to start this great adventure? As long as approaching alphabet awareness is relaxed and fun, can it be too early? I do not think so. Especially when early literacy lessons can be something as fun as a dance party with songs like these:

 
          

No comments:

Post a Comment