I openly admit
that I have been guilty of being a harsh grader when it comes to spelling. In
my novice understanding of teaching, I thought that pointing out the correct way
to spell something was always important. I did not realize that by always being
such a stickler, I was missing the bigger picture. Constantly pointing out errors
can be overwhelming and damaging to self-esteem. It also draws attention away from
the main goal of writing; to express an idea.
My mistaken approach is not an
uncommon one. In Kate Foley Cusumano's article Every Mark on the Page: Educating Family and Community Members about
Young Children's Writing, she comments “I have seen the fun go out of
writing when family members get involved, especially when they demand adult
writing conventions from six-and seven-year-olds.” We are incorrectly expecting
these children to think just like us. The actual purpose of writing is also
being ignored when we demand polished writing too early in development. For
example, a child writes “I skor a gol.” She has adequately gotten across the
idea that she has scored a goal. This should be looked at as a success. In
time, she can continue to develop her phonemic awareness and hone in on
polishing her written expressions. It
is important for her to explore this early understanding of how sounds and
letters are related without harsh criticism that might cause her to have a
negative association with writing.
In Sound
Systems (Lyon and Moore, 2003), present the idea that the brain uses patterns
to decipher words versus applying rules. With this idea in mind, it is not surprising
that a child would make an error such as writing ‘jagn for dragon.” In fact it
makes sense if you look at the fact that the child has most likely learned to
speak prior to leaning to read and write. Their brain is identifying a known
pattern that “The sounds /j/ and /dr/ are affricate and are pronounced with
similar mouth positions.” What might look like a silly mistake, actually has
logic behind it.
Just as we have learned
how to give students the space and the freedom to construct their own
understanding of math concepts, we need to give the space and time for students
to learn the patterns of written language and the abundant anomalies of
English. We cannot just tell them the correct answers and expect them to retain
the idea. They must learn why something is correct and they must construct this
understanding on their own.
No comments:
Post a Comment