Brain Cambourne’s article Toward
an educationally relevant theory of literacy learning: Twenty years of inquiry
was a particularly engrossing article for me.
Cambourne’s musings over the prevailing
theories of education at the time and the conflicting observations that he saw
during the beginning of his teaching years, struck a strong chord with me. I
certainly understand that there are incidents of neurological impairments that
create true cognitive learning deficits. However, if the culture was changed on how we
look at the variety of learning processes, how many learning ‘disabilities’
could be reframed as learning differences. I became acutely aware of this idea
from an experience that I had in high school. A dear friend had received a very
low grade in a math class and was incredibly upset and crying because he took
this negative school event as proof that he was “just stupid”. This individual
happened to be an incredible artist. Honestly, he possesses a true rare talent
that specifically allows him to draw photo realistic sketches and in general he
has an innate understanding of perspective that is mind blowing. Fast forward
twenty years and he is now an accomplished artist with a master’s degree. His
work has been shown on at least three continents. The fact that his life took
this trajectory does not surprise me in the least bit. However, it always has
bothered me that an individual with so keen an intellect and talent could have
been lead to believe that he was intellectually inferior because he did poorly
in one teachers math class or in one specific type of learning environment.
What are we missing out on if some brilliant thinkers are lead to believe that they
are less than for not fitting into one model of learning?
I strongly
agree with Cambourne’s discomfort with children’s failings immediately being
labeled as deficits. His discussion of this concept reminded me of the current disaccord
in the psychology community surrounding the concept of the deficiency model
versus the wellness model. http://psycnet.apa.org/psycinfo/2001-00169-011
It was particularly helpful that he explored
the idea that a major issue with using a repetitive drill or rote memorization
approach to teaching, was that it “accorded a special status to errors.” Of course,
the status placed on errors in this approach frames them as negative occurrences
rather than utilizing them as vital teaching moments in the learning process.
It is important to learn and teach the fact that humans by their very nature
make mistakes. If we teach our children that mistakes are “wrong” or shameful,
then what learning opportunities are we missing out on? How are we impacting
their self-esteem? How do these persistent attacks on their self-esteem
influence their long-term learning? This is an area that I would like to
explore more.
When
Cambourne began to discuss the ‘conditions of learning’ and how they applied to
literacy learning, it became impossible for me to separate my lens as an
educator and my lens as a mother.
I am raising a preliterate child
who is defined as non-verbal. However, he uses American Sign Language as his
expressive language on the cognitive level of his peers. He signs up to four
word sentences and has a large vocabulary. Because his stroke impacted the function
of the muscles of his mouth, he is not able to coordinate them yet to form the
sounds of oral language. However, he has been able to learn receptive language
at the same rate as his peers. What has been fascinating has been that we have
learned from his speech pathologist that a recent study has found that
non-verbal children will use sign approximations in the same way that a verbal
child will used verbal approximations or “baby talk”. It raises the idea that learning
the thought of language is not necessarily dependent on the ability to orally speak.
I thought that Cambourne’s look at the
importance of attention in the engagement and responsibility phases was
interesting. It is fascinating that attention becomes so vital to learning during
the developmental stages that are highlighted by the will of the child
beginning to sharpen its claws in such a pronounced way. As any parent knows,
in the preverbal and preliterate stages the child’s will to pay attention can
become a dominant tool to gain power in a situation.
I was
also intrigued by Camborne’s idea that during this time of language acquisition,
spoken language is usually presented in its whole, natural form rather than
being broken up into “predetermined sequences”. This brings to mind the work of
Nancy Kaufman who specializes in treating children with verbal apraxia. Her
work relies on breaking language down into very specific progressive steps. Her
work has reminded me before of an ‘oral phonics’ of sorts. The question that
arises for me after reading this article is if there is a strong correlation
between how children acquire language skills and how they become literate; does
Cambourne’s article in fact promote the idea of teaching text literacy with a whole
language literacy education model rather than teaching with phonics? #iubece @DrWohlwend
Fascinating post and so many insights! I'm excited to see the connections you make across sign systems as we learn more about approximations and scaffolding young learners!
ReplyDelete